How we compare and score vendors
One formula, applied the same way to every vendor. Nine measures add up to a score out of 100, and each measure is also shown on its own.
- 9
- 0 to 100
- 14 days
- None
The score formula
Points available per measure. A vendor's measure score (0 to 100) earns that share of the points.
| Measure | Points | What we check | How points are given |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | 20 | Price per mg against the median of all vendors for the same peptide and vial size; bulk discounts; payment methods. | 30% below the median earns all points, 50% above earns none. |
| Lab testing | 20 | Third-party COA with a link, named lab, batch-level testing, HPLC and mass spec disclosed, stated purity. | Points for each item, checked against the vendor's linked reports. |
| Consumer complaints | 12 | Share of 1 and 2 star reviews, share of negative reviews answered, BBB standing. | 2% low-star or less earns full marks; 20% or more earns none. |
| Licences and credentials | 10 | Business registration found in a state registry, accredited testing lab, GMP or ISO manufacturing stated, no FDA warning letter. | Verified items carry most points; vendor statements carry few. |
| Delivery | 10 | Delivery problems in recent reviews, dispatch time, lost package cover, tracking, US fulfilment. | No problems in the sample earns full marks for that item. |
| Shipping price | 8 | Standard shipping cost to a US address and the free-shipping threshold. | Free earns all points, falling to none at $20. |
| Transparency | 8 | Entity name, street address, phone, email, refund, shipping, privacy and terms pages, 2+ years established. | A block of points for each item present and working. |
| Availability | 6 | Share of tracked products in stock and catalog size. | Measured at every check. |
| Reviews and support | 6 | Trustpilot and Google rating adjusted for review count; email, phone, chat, published hours. | Review average is weighted by count, so a handful of reviews can't dominate. |
Rating bands
A letter beside every score, so it never relies on colour alone.
- Band A85 to 100Strong on price and on every record we check
- Band B70 to 84Strong overall, one or two weaker measures
- Band C55 to 69Mixed: check the breakdown before ordering
- Band D40 to 54Several gaps in what the vendor publishes
- Band EBelow 40Little could be verified
Top pick for each peptide
A second score, per offer.
Buy score = 50% the offer's price score against the median for that vial size + 50% the vendor's score on the eight non-price measures. The highest Buy score is the Top pick. The cheapest in-stock offer is shown as Lowest price, and the vendor with the best overall score as Highest-rated vendor.
An offer must be in stock, from a scored vendor, with a linked certificate of analysis. Otherwise it can be the Lowest price but not the Top pick.
What we can't measure. No vendor publishes a delivery rate. Our delivery measure counts problems in the most recent reviews and reads the published policy.
Provisional scores
Registration, FDA warning letter, BBB, review and delivery figures count only after a second check by our team. Until then they score zero and the score is marked provisional.
When a vendor has no score
Fewer than 5 visible prices, or less than 75% of fields researched. It shows as "Under review" with the reason.
Who is not scored at all
Marketplaces, catalogs behind a sign-in and businesses that don't sell research peptides.
Corrections
Use "Report an error" on any vendor page. We check the source and log the change within 5 business days.
Where the data comes from
Vendor websites
Prices, vial sizes, stock, shipping and refund policies, payment methods, contact details and linked lab reports.
Trustpilot and Google
Ratings, review counts, the share of 1 and 2 star reviews, replies to them, and delivery problems in recent reviews.
Better Business Bureau
BBB rating and accreditation, where the vendor has a profile.
State business registries
Whether the business entity is registered and active.
FDA warning letters
The FDA's public warning letter database, matched by company name and confirmed before it is shown.
Our checks
Every vendor page shows the date of the latest check. Figures not re-checked for more than 30 days are flagged on the page.
Common questions
- How is a vendor's score calculated?
- Nine measures, from price to lab testing and delivery, are each scored from 0 to 100 and weighted into one score out of 100. The weights are published on this page and are the same for every vendor.
- How often is the data checked?
- Every vendor is re-checked at least every 14 days. Scores are recalculated every day and whenever a record changes, and each vendor page shows the date of its latest check.
- Can a vendor pay for a better score or ranking?
- No. We don't accept payment, sponsorship or commissions from any vendor, and no vendor can pay to change its ranking. There are no manual overrides: every score comes from the same formula.
- Why does a vendor have no score?
- A score needs at least 5 visible prices and 75% of the fields researched. Until then the vendor shows as "Under review" with the reason. Marketplaces, catalogs behind a sign-in and businesses that don't sell research peptides are not scored at all.
- What does a provisional score mean?
- Registration, FDA warning letter, BBB, review and delivery figures count only after a second check by our team. Until then they score zero and the score is marked provisional.
- Where does the data come from?
- Vendor websites, Trustpilot and Google reviews, the Better Business Bureau, state business registries and the FDA's warning letter database. Each figure is shown with its source and the date it was checked.
- How do I report a mistake?
- Use "Report an error" on the vendor's page, or the contact form. We check the source and log the change within 5 business days.
- How does a vendor get listed?
- Anyone can submit a website, free of charge. It is listed once it meets our listing criteria and an editor has checked its data. Being listed never changes a score.